Audits

GLOBALG.A.P. vs SIZA: do you need both?

FieldSafe team · Draft, scheduled

FieldSafe All audits screen: one card per farm task with a pill for each audit that asks for it
All audits: one card per farm task, with a pill for each audit that asks for it.

Often, yes. GLOBALG.A.P. and SIZA do different jobs: GLOBALG.A.P. IFA is mainly about food safety and good agricultural practice, while SIZA is about how you treat people (Social) and the environment (Environmental). Many South African export farms are asked for both, and a large part of the evidence is the same, so you can keep one set of records for both.

Different jobs

Start with what each one is for.

GLOBALG.A.P. IFA (Integrated Farm Assurance) answers the buyer’s question: is this produce grown safely and traceably? It covers food safety, the safe use of plant protection products, workers’ health and safety, environmental care, and traceability from the Block to dispatch. A certification body inspects the farm, and the result is a GLOBALG.A.P. certificate. FieldSafe maps IFA v6 GFS, 191 control points in its own words. See GLOBALG.A.P. IFA v6 in plain words.

SIZA (the Sustainability Initiative of South Africa) answers a different question: are the people and the land being treated fairly and responsibly? It has two standards:

  • SIZA Social: labour law, contracts, wages and hours, health and safety, worker voice. FieldSafe maps SIZA Social 7.0, 143 control points.
  • SIZA Environmental: water, soil, energy, waste and biodiversity. FieldSafe maps SIZA Environmental 2.1, 191 control points.

SIZA starts with a self-assessment on MySIZA, and after the audit and any corrections it issues an Audit Completion Letter, not a certificate. See SIZA Social vs SIZA Environmental for the side-by-side.

There is a third piece worth knowing: GRASP, GLOBALG.A.P.’s own add-on for social practice. Some buyers ask for GRASP, some for SIZA Social, some accept either; ask your buyer which one they want. See GRASP explained.

GLOBALG.A.P. IFA v6SIZA SocialSIZA Environmental
Main questionIs the produce grown safely and traceably?Are people treated fairly and safely?Is the farm managing its impact?
Who runs itGLOBALG.A.P., via certification bodiesSIZA, via approved audit firmsSIZA, via approved audit firms
Starting pointRegistration and self-assessmentMySIZA self-assessmentMySIZA self-assessment
OutcomeCertificate from the certification bodyAudit Completion LetterAudit Completion Letter
Mapped in FieldSafe191 control points (GFS)143 control points (7.0)191 control points (2.1)

Which audits you need is your buyer’s decision. Ask your exporter or packhouse in writing which standards each market requires.

Where they overlap

The standards are written by different organisations for different purposes, but they look at the same farm. Wherever two standards ask about the same work, the same record can prove both.

Common areas of overlap:

  • Chemical handling and spraying. GLOBALG.A.P. looks at food safety and correct use; SIZA Social looks at the safety of the operator; SIZA Environmental looks at protecting water and soil. One complete spray record, naming who sprayed with what PPE and which sprayer, speaks to all three.
  • Training. Spray-operator training, first aid, hygiene and safety briefings appear across GLOBALG.A.P., GRASP and SIZA Social.
  • Water. Sources, permits, meter readings and use appear in GLOBALG.A.P. and SIZA Environmental. Clean drinking water for workers appears in SIZA Social too.
  • Waste. Empty containers, oil and other waste appear in GLOBALG.A.P. and SIZA Environmental.
  • Incidents and emergencies. Spill response and emergency procedures appear across the board.
  • Risk assessments and policies. Each standard asks for its own set, but they often cover overlapping ground.

What does not overlap much: GLOBALG.A.P.’s detail on harvest hygiene and traceability, and SIZA Social’s detail on wages, contracts and working hours. Those need their own attention.

A practical example

Pieter grows macadamias and avocados on 70 hectares near Hazyview. His packhouse asks for GLOBALG.A.P. IFA v6 and SIZA Social this year, with SIZA Environmental likely next year.

In FieldSafe, he switches audits on and opens All audits. Each card is one farm task, with a pill for every audit that asks for it. The card for training people to handle chemicals safely carries pills for GLOBALG.A.P., GRASP and SIZA Social. Because his team records toolbox talks and spray-operator training in bulk, that card already shows evidence, for every audit at once.

An audit card's side panel in FieldSafe: how it stands, what good looks like and the checks per audit
An audit card's side panel: how it stands, what good looks like, and the checks per audit.

The water-source card carries pills for GLOBALG.A.P. and SIZA Environmental. His borehole, with its permit reference, and his monthly meter readings already count for both. When SIZA Environmental comes next year, a large part of the work will already be done.

The SIZA Environmental add-on

There is a SIZA Environmental add-on that can be combined with a GLOBALG.A.P. IFA audit, so the environmental part is assessed during the same visit. GLOBALG.A.P. lists SIZA on its solutions page, and SIZA’s Environmental audit process and methodology document explains how the environmental audit works.

Whether the add-on makes sense for you depends on your buyers, your certification body and the current rules. How it is booked, what it costs and how the results are reported can change. Check the current official document and ask your certification body whether they offer it and what it involves.

The practical benefit is fewer audit days on the farm. The records you need are the same either way.

One set of records for both

The mistake to avoid is keeping a GLOBALG.A.P. binder and a separate SIZA binder, each with its own copy of the training register and the water readings. Two copies drift apart. Then one of them is wrong on the day.

Keep one set of records, captured as the work happens, and let each audit point to the same evidence.

This is how FieldSafe is built:

  • Audits are a switch. FieldSafe is a farm tool first. Switch on only the audits you need.
  • 593 control points, 221 farm tasks. The four audits FieldSafe maps (GLOBALG.A.P. IFA v6 GFS, GRASP v2, SIZA Social 7.0 and SIZA Environmental 2.1) are grouped into 221 plain-language farm tasks.
  • One record counts for every audit that asks for it. Link a record or document to a farm task once, and it counts wherever that task appears.
  • Records fill audits automatically. Ten everyday record streams, including sprays, fertiliser, irrigation, water sources, training, operator credentials, calibration, scouting, incidents and harvest traceability, count where their details prove the item.
  • “Not needed here” comes from your farm’s facts, not a long questionnaire, and you can override it.
  • Counts, never scores. Each audit shows how many items have evidence, how many are missing, how many need a look and how many are not needed here.
  • Today and the Calendar show the few things that move the most audits forward.
  • Audit packs are frozen exactly as issued, with gaps listed honestly.

For SIZA, think of FieldSafe as the place to get ready for MySIZA. It does not replace MySIZA or connect to it; it helps you have the evidence ready when you answer the self-assessment and when the auditor arrives.

See one record serve both

See how FieldSafe lays out all four audits, including GLOBALG.A.P. IFA v6 and SIZA Social. FieldSafe is in early access: join early access and see one record count for every audit that asks for it.

FieldSafe helps you prepare; certification is decided by your certification body.

Early access

Be one of the first farms on FieldSafe.

FieldSafe is in early access. Join, and we help you set up your farm and try it on your team's own phones.

Join early access