Compare
Paper and spreadsheets vs FieldSafe
Most farms keep records on paper, in WhatsApp and in spreadsheets. That works, up to a point. Here is where it stops working, and where it still wins.
This page is for farm owners and managers deciding whether to move their farm records off paper and spreadsheets. It compares the two honestly, row by row, including what paper still does better.
Side by side
How paper, spreadsheets and FieldSafe compare
The same jobs, done two ways. Read the last row too.
| What | Paper and spreadsheets | FieldSafe |
|---|---|---|
| Where the record is made | On a sheet in the bakkie, or typed up later from memory, often on a Friday afternoon. | On the phone, in the Block, while the job is done. The office plans on a desk screen. |
| Signal | Paper needs none. A spreadsheet needs a computer, usually in the office. | Works with no signal. Work saves on the phone and sends itself later. Planning and some look-ups need a connection. |
| Who records | Usually one person who can read and write the forms, copying from others. | Supervisors record a whole team at once. Workers get picture-led screens, read-aloud and English or Afrikaans. |
| Finding a record later | Paging through files, folders and WhatsApp chats. Photos often have no Block or date. | Each record sits in the Block's history, with its photos, and every list exports to CSV. |
| Corrections and history | Crossed out, overwritten, or a new version of the file. Who changed what is usually lost. | Managers correct anything, even accepted work. History keeps itself quietly. Remove can be undone. |
| Spray holds | Worked out by hand and written on a board or a sheet, if someone remembers. | "Do not pick before" and "Keep out until" show on the Block, the map and every phone. FieldSafe warns rather than blocks, and does not check the label. |
| Stock | A separate stock book or sheet that drifts from what was actually used. | Sprays and feeding take stock off their batch. Correcting a record moves only the difference. |
| Audits | A binder built in the weeks before the audit, chasing missing pages. | If you switch audits on, everyday records show as evidence, with counts of what is still missing. Never a score. |
| Cost | Paper is cheap. The real cost is the hours spent copying, typing up and searching. | FieldSafe is in early access with no published price yet. Pricing will be in rand, per farm. |
| What paper does better | Needs no phone, no signal, no charging and no training. Everyone already knows how it works. | FieldSafe needs a phone and a little setup. It is new: built and working on a test environment with a small group of test users. |
Being honest
Where paper still wins
- It needs no phone, no signal, no battery and no training.
- Everyone on the farm already knows how to use it.
- It costs almost nothing to start.
- Many auditors and buyers are used to seeing it.
If your farm is small, your team is steady and your records are in good order, paper may be enough for now. Our free printable templates can help either way.
Where it gets hard
Where paper and spreadsheets fall short
- The record is made after the job, by someone who was not there.
- The same spray goes on the spray sheet, the stock book and the audit binder.
- Nobody sees a spray hold unless someone writes it on the board.
- Corrections leave no clear history of who changed what.
- Before an audit, someone spends weeks building a binder.
Where FieldSafe stands
FieldSafe is new, and in early access
FieldSafe is built and working on a test environment with a small group of test users. There is no public launch and no published price yet. Early-access farms get help to set up, try it on their team's own phones, and have a say in what comes next.
You don't have to switch everything at once. You can start with one record, such as sprays, and keep paper for the rest while you try it. FieldSafe can also keep your existing records: import a staff list, or add a scanned record to keep. Files are kept exactly as given, not read automatically.
Paper still has a place. Print our free record templates: spray records, fertiliser, irrigation, harvest, trap counts, training and more. Each comes with a CSV download, so you can move to FieldSafe later without retyping.
Keep going
FAQ
Questions about moving off paper
Does it work without signal in the orchard?
Yes. Recording work, completing jobs, trap and rain readings, team records, problem reports and photos all work with no signal. Work is saved on the phone and sends itself when there is signal, and the map keeps working from GPS and your saved Blocks.
Planning, satellite pictures and some look-ups need a connection. How offline works.
Do my workers need to download an app from the Play Store?
No. FieldSafe is a web app that installs from the browser ("Add to home screen") on Android and iPhone. Workers can join by scanning a QR code, and they don't need an email address. How to add it to a home screen.
Can I import what I already have?
Yes. Staff lists (CSV or XLSX), certificates and audit reports, lab reports, fertiliser advice and "a record to keep" (PDF, photos or Word) can be added. Files are kept exactly as given and shown next to the details you confirm. FieldSafe does not read scans automatically. Documents and imports.
How much does it cost?
FieldSafe is in early access and has no published price yet. Pricing will be in rand, per farm, with seasonal billing in mind. Join early access to hear first and to get founding terms. How pricing will work.
Early access
Try FieldSafe beside your paper records.
FieldSafe is in early access. Join, and we help you set up your farm and try it on your team's own phones, at your pace.