Audits
IFA v6 Smart vs GFS: which one do you need?
Let your market decide. IFA v6 GFS is the edition for buyers who require certification recognised by the Global Food Safety Initiative (GFSI); IFA v6 Smart is the edition for markets that do not. Ask your exporter or buyer which one they need, in writing, before you book the audit.
The short answer
GLOBALG.A.P. Integrated Farm Assurance version 6 comes in two editions. Both cover the same big topics: food safety, the safe use of plant protection products, workers’ health and safety, the environment, and traceability. The farm work is the same. The difference is what the certificate is recognised for.
- IFA v6 GFS. This is the edition recognised by GFSI, a global body that benchmarks food-safety schemes. Some retailers and food companies only accept certificates from schemes that GFSI recognises. If one of your buyers is in that group, you need GFS.
- IFA v6 Smart. The edition for buyers who accept GLOBALG.A.P. without asking for GFSI recognition.
The certification body Kiwa explains the difference in more depth, and GLOBALG.A.P. publishes both editions and their transition tools on globalgap.org. Rules on which buyers recognise which edition change over time; check the current official document and confirm with your buyer.
| IFA v6 Smart | IFA v6 GFS | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | GLOBALG.A.P. farm assurance, edition without GFSI recognition | GLOBALG.A.P. farm assurance, edition recognised by GFSI |
| Who usually asks | Buyers who accept GLOBALG.A.P. as it is | Buyers whose policy requires a GFSI-recognised scheme |
| Farm topics | Food safety, plant protection, workers, environment, traceability | The same topics, with the extra requirements GFSI benchmarking needs |
| Who decides | Your market | Your market |
Who asks for GFS
GFSI recognition matters most to large retailers and food companies that have a policy of only buying from GFSI-recognised schemes. Kiwa notes that GFS is mostly asked for by buyers in the United States. Many other buyers accept GLOBALG.A.P. without asking for GFSI recognition, but policies differ from buyer to buyer and change over time.
For a South African grower, the practical point is this: you rarely choose the edition yourself. You find out what each buyer and market needs through your exporter, packhouse or marketing agent, then pick the edition that covers all of them.
If one of your markets needs GFS and the others accept either, GFS will usually cover everyone. If none of your buyers needs GFSI recognition, Smart may be enough. Confirm this with your buyer rather than assuming.
A practical example
Johan grows citrus on 80 hectares near Letsitele. Most of his fruit goes to Europe and the Middle East through one exporter. This season the exporter has a new programme with a North American retailer and asks whether Johan can supply it.
Johan asks the exporter to confirm in writing what that retailer requires. The answer: GFSI-recognised certification, so IFA v6 GFS, plus GRASP. His European buyers accept GFS too. He books one audit for IFA v6 GFS with GRASP alongside, rather than juggling two editions.
What changes in practice
On the farm, very little changes between the two. Spray records, fertiliser records, water, training, harvest hygiene and traceability matter in both. Most of the work of preparing is the same work.
Where they differ, GFS carries the additional requirements needed for GFSI benchmarking. The details, such as which control points are added or carry a stricter level, are in the official checklists. We are not going to list them here, partly because they are GLOBALG.A.P.’s text and partly because they change between versions. Compare the two checklists on globalgap.org, or ask your certification body to walk you through the differences that apply to your crop.
A few practical points that hold either way:
- The audit day feels similar. The auditor still picks a Block, follows a spray record through to the store, checks training and tests traceability.
- Your records are the same records. You do not keep a “GFS spray record” and a “Smart spray record”. You keep one good spray record.
- Switching later is easier if your records are complete. A farm on Smart that keeps full records will find a move to GFS much less work.
- Add-ons sit on top of either edition. GRASP, for example, is assessed alongside your IFA inspection whichever edition you hold. Ask your certification body how add-ons combine with the edition you choose.
The biggest risk is not picking the “wrong” edition. It is preparing late. A grower who finds out six weeks before the season that a new buyer needs GFS has very little time to book an audit, run a self-assessment and fix gaps. Ask early, ideally before the season’s first sprays, so the records you capture from day one are the ones the auditor will see.
Where FieldSafe fits
FieldSafe maps IFA v6 GFS: 191 control points in FieldSafe’s own words, grouped with GRASP, SIZA Social and SIZA Environmental into 221 farm tasks. It does not map the Smart edition separately. If your buyer accepts Smart, most farm tasks will look familiar, but check the Smart checklist itself before relying on any mapping.
Once audits are switched on, the One audit view lists each control point as a row, with counts in the header: with evidence, missing, need a look, not needed here. FieldSafe never shows a score or percentage. Each card shows the level of each check (major must, minor must or recommendation), so you can deal with the most important gaps first. Your everyday spray records, training and water records count automatically where their details prove the item.
Ask your exporter these three questions
Before you book anything, send your exporter, packhouse or buyer these three questions. Ask for the answers in writing, by email or WhatsApp, so you have them on file.
- “Which IFA v6 edition does each of my buyers require: Smart or GFS?” If different buyers need different things, ask which edition covers all of them.
- “Do any of my buyers need add-ons with it?” Common ones in South Africa are GRASP for social practice and the SIZA Environmental add-on. Some buyers also have their own retailer requirements.
- “By when must the certificate be valid, and which certification bodies do you accept?” This sets your timeline. Work back from the date, and leave room for corrective actions after the audit.
With those answers you can choose a certification body, book a date and plan backwards. Our 90-day plan for a first audit shows how to space out the work. For a plain-words tour of what the auditor looks at, read GLOBALG.A.P. IFA v6 in plain words.
One thing to avoid
Do not guess the edition from what a neighbour uses. Two farms on the same road can sell to different buyers with different rules. Get the answer from your own exporter or buyer.
Not sure which edition you need?
Book a 20-minute walkthrough and we will show you how FieldSafe lays out GLOBALG.A.P. IFA v6 for your farm, or join early access.
FieldSafe helps you prepare; certification is decided by your certification body.